Sadly, these have been a difficult couple of years. For one thing, Health issues within the extended family and increasing responsibilities in other areas of life have made it difficult to actively work on new Five String builds. Consequently, I hardly get started, and something else is needed
However, currently, I have one new Five-string Fiddle that should be done in the near future.
Originally, I bought the figured maple for this five string instrument as a billet, years ago, from Bruce Harvie of “Orcas Island Tonewoods.” However, the European Spruce, the purfling, and the fittings are from “International Violin Company” in Baltimore. Serendipitously, I secured the linings and blocks from a local source. They are weeping willow, (And it came from a large downed limb in someone’s yard after a windstorm).
This is my original design from the first five-string fiddle I built. For some reason, it has proved my most popular build, both for tone and playability.
Scroll Graft
Obviously, (If you look closely, you can see it) I was forced to perform a scroll graft on this instrument. The cause was that there was a series of small knots that penetrated all the way through the neck, right at the nut line. As a result, they would have produced a fatal weakness in the neck. I had already carved most of the scroll when I realized it wasn’t going to work.
Also, obviously, (fortunately,) I had a block of curly maple at hand that could be shaped into a new neck-block and grafted into the scroll.
Five String Progress Photos:
Completed Back PlateCompleted Garland and Front PlateFront PlateTreble Side of Five String Neck with FingerboardFront View of Neck with FingerboardBass side view of Five String Neck with FingerboardFront view of completed White Five-String FiddleBass side view of Completed Fiddle in the WhiteBack view of Completed Five String Fiddle in the white
The next step will be to complete final smoothing and varnish preparation, then I will apply a mineral ground. Finally, after the ground is fully dry, I will apply a coat of a sealing compound. Then I can begin varnishing.
Last time, I gave a preview of some of the finishing and varnishing procedures.
But, to be more specific, let’s walk through the varnishing process:
Bare wood, front view before finishing
Bare wood, back view before finishing
Finishing Preparations for Varnish
First, I removed the fingerboard to give me access to every square millimeter of the outside of the instrument. Next, I used low-angle light, to cast dark shadows so that I could see all the discontinuities, humps and hollows. Then, I gently scraped all the surfaces to remove all of those discontinuities.
Finally, I was ready for finishing: the varnish procedure:
Bare wood, scraped and ready for finish
First Step in Finishing is a Mineral Ground to Close the Pores
To begin with, I used a suspension of fine particles of gypsum in either water or coffee, to form a mineral ground. First, I brushed the mixture onto all the outside surface except the handle area of the neck, Then, using my fingers, I rubbed the mixture into the wood, so as to fill the natural pores with “nano-particles” of the gypsum.
After the mixture dries, the instrument looks chalk-white, and the mineral ground obscures the wood grain.
Dry Gypsum, Front View
Side View, Dry Gypsum ground.
Back view, Dry Gypsum ground
Scroll with Dry Gypsum ground
Then, I used 400-grit sandpaper to very lightly rub off any excess dry gypsum, which still left the violin looking stark-white, as the gypsum had filled the pores of the wood. this is all part of finishing.
Obviously, that (mineral ground) stage of the process looks pretty awful. but the next step (sealer application) always feels like “magic” to me. The sealer makes the mineral ground permanently “disappear!”
Finishing Moves Forward With Sealer
For the last ten years, or so. I have used a sealer which is simply a thin solution of rosin in alcohol. Sometimes, I use turpentine instead of (or in addition to) the alcohol. Either way, the solvent carries the rosin into the pores, surrounding the particles of gypsum, and thereby rendering the particles transparent. (However, on this fiddle, I chose to use alcohol as the solvent.)
Front view with sealer
Side View With Sealer
Back View With Sealer
Scroll With Sealer
Obviously, the mineral ground has done its work, plugging the pores against penetration by varnish. However, it has also become permanently invisible.
Finishing for Real: NOW we Varnish!
When I began making violins, I was using oil varnishes. Later, I switched to spirit varnishes. Today, I am still using a spirit varnish.
The main chemical difference between the two is that an oil varnish is composed of a mixture of a drying oil and a resin of some kind. The varnish-maker cooked the oil and resins together at a high heat, thereby forming a polymer, which is no longer either oil or resin. It does not dry by evaporation so much as by a continuation of the polymerization process, and by “off-gassing” the volatile portions left in the mix.
Varnish makers prepare the spirit varnishes, on the other hand, by dissolving one or more resins in a solvent. Incidentally, the solvent is usually, (but not always) alcohol. When the solvent evaporates, the resin (or resins) remain(s) in and on the wood, to finish hardening. (The mineral ground helps to prevent deep penetration of the varnish into the wood. This is desirable because the varnish-saturated wood does not vibrate the same in comparison to the unsaturated wood, and it can thereby dampen the sound.)
I always begin with a yellow varnish, so that the yellow base coats will “shine through” any thin areas of the darker vanish, providing a reflective “glow” from within.
Yellow Varnish Base Coats
Here is the fiddle with two coats of yellow varnish:
Front View, two coats Yellow
Side View, Two Coats Yellow
Back view with two coats yellow varnish
Scroll with two coats yellow
The grain begins to become more visible with the addition of the varnish. There is a temptation to stop early, because the grain becomes highly visible after about three or four coats of varnish. But it will look better with more.
Building the Color
I began deepening the color by simply adding a thin coat of brown varnish, over the yellow base coats.
Deepening the color: one coat brown varnish.
I loved this look…it seemed as though the Quilted Maple wood was in flames, during finishing. Or perhaps as if I was seeing an incredibly dramatic sunset in progress. But I knew it needed more.
Two coats brown over yellow. Back
Brown (two coats) over yellow, front view
Scroll with Brown varnish over Yellow
Shading comes into Play
Obviously, (as you can see) I am applying more color in certain areas. I am attempting, thereby, to give the impression of truly aged varnish (where the colored varnish has been worn away in certain areas through much use.) Some people don’t like that look, but many do. Most importantly, Ilike it. Charles Beare was famously quoted as having said, “There is absolutely no reason to ‘antique’ or ‘shade’ a new instrument during finishing...unless you actually hope to sellit!” (Apparently I’m in good company!)
So, I apply more varnish in the areas where hands would be least likely to touch, and where the surface is least likely to be abraded by any means. But, I try to be gentle about this, not heavy-handed. Some (few) makers deliberately damage the wood, in an effort to imitate advanced age. Their instruments sell to people who like that look, but I don’t want to do that. Therefore. I simply brush on deeper color in the areas of least wear. All part of Finishing!
Usually, I prefer instruments to be at least a little leaning toward a red-brown color, so, I needed to add some red.
Finishing: Needs More Color
I brushed on a thin coat of red-brown varnish all over:
Back view, leaning toward red
Front view, leaning toward red
Scroll, leaning toward Red
But it still needed more! Consequently, I added more brown in the corners, and allowed it to dry. Then I added more red. (All part of finishing.)
Shading begun, with more red
Back with more red
Scroll with more red
Finishing: Finally, the varnish reached a depth of color about which I felt pretty good!
Finishing: Final Color Front
Finishing: Final Color Back
Finishing: Scroll in its Final color
Then, as a final step in finishing, I french-polished the instrument, to flatten any brush-marks. Now I will allow it to dry and harden for a couple of weeks before I set it up for playing. (Otherwise, it will acquire deep fingerprints as I work on it.)
Finishing Includes How a Violin is Completed, Varnished, and Set Up
Last time I posted, I had just completed the commissioned five-string fiddle, up to and including the sealer, but I did not address the actual finishing.
Sealed instrument, Front View
Sealed instrument, Back View.
Finishing includes Varnish:
The “magic” of the sealer was that it caused the mineral ground to disappear forever. The instrument instantly went from stark chalk-white to a natural wood color. As a result, the mineral will never be visible again. I always enjoy that transformation.
The varnish, on the other hand, is a series of relatively small changes, wherein the violin achieves the color we want through finishing. Furthermore, the increasing clarity and depth of the varnish gives the impression of being able to “see into the wood.”
I always begin with a couple of coats of deepyellow or amber varnish, as an undercoat which will shine through the later color coats. all part of “finishing.”
Yellow First
Here is the violin in process of finishing, after the two coats of yellow varnish:
Front View, with Yellow base coat.
Yellow base coat, Treble Side View.
Back View with Yellow base coat.
Finishing: Color Coats
Next, I began layering the color coats, building to the look I planned. (Each “coat,” in the finishing process, is usually two coats, applied in quick succession. There were about eighttotal color coats, but I will call them “first through fourth.”)
First Color Coat, Front
Treble Side, with First Color Coat.
First Color Coat, Back
Bass Side, with First Color Coat.
This maple is really beautiful wood. I wish I had a lot more of it, but, sadly, I only was able to salvage a little of the tree from which it originated. The “donor tree” was removed from the property where my wife and her siblings grew up. It had finally rotted and was becoming dangerous, so they removed it. But finishing shows that the wood is gorgeous. You can see the stump in this article….
Finishing: Continuing color coats
As you can see, the yellow base coat is still showing through pretty strongly. That is good, but I still wanted to move the color toward a deep reddish brown, through proper finishing, with the golden yellow shining through. Therefore… I needed more color coats!
Second Color Coat, Front
Back, with Second Color Coat.
The color is headed in the right direction, but still needs to be deeper. I will add extra color in any areas that should be darker. All part of finishing.
Third Color Coat, Front.
Oregon Big Leaf Maple Back, withThird Color Coat.
I was getting pretty close to correct, so I began taking the instrument out into natural light, to check the color there, to see what the finishing process had actually accomplished.
Fourth Color Coat, Front.
Treble Side with Fourth Color Coat.
Back Side, with Fourth Color Coat.
Bass side, Fourth Color Coat.
The color was pretty close to what I had hoped to produce through finishing. Therefore, I felt that I was ready to reinstall the fingerboard, Afterward, I would hand-rub the varnish to a good polish. Finally, I allowed it to hang in my dining room and cure a little more fully. The varnish was still quite soft, though dry to the touch.
Finishing the Fingerboard
First I carved the underside of the fingerboard to remove extra mass. I buy Fingerboards as blanks, so they require a lot of finishing, carving, and scraping. This affects the sound, as well as the feel of the instrument. (Extra, unnecessary mass tends to absorb vibration rather than resonate.)
Underside of fingerboard beginning. It was fully carved and smoothed before installation.
Then I carved a tiny notch, dead center on the upper end of the backside of the fingerboard, where it would contact the neck. After carving the notch in the fingerboard, I drilled a shallow 1/16″ hole in the neck, at an angle, to accommodate a tiny nail.
That nail is temporarily installed, at an angle, to serve as a guide and an anchor while installing the fingerboard. (The hide glue is very slippery while it is still hot, and liquid. There is a tendency for the fingerboard to “drift” under the clamps, before the glue can gel.) Finishing installation is tricky: it is easy to miss errors.
The notch in the fingerboard fits on the nail. The nail, then, serves as a temporary stop, so the fingerboard stays put. (I remove the nail after the glue has set.)
Fingerboard installed. Notice the tiny nail used to temporarily position the fingerboard.
Beginning Set-up
After a few more days, I began set-up. First, I installed the soundpost, saddle, nut, and end button. Next, I fit the pegs, and was ready for the bridge and the strings.
Nut installed: it will be filed lower before installing strings.
Saddle installed, still requiring final smoothing and retouch.
You can see in the above photo that the varnish was still very soft. Everywhere I touched it, it also resulted in my leaving fingerprints. I had to “French-polish” the whole instrument afterward, and let it hang until the varnish was harder. Then it would be easier to handle. (But it was good to have the set-up nearing completion, too.)
Completed five-string fiddle ready for varnish retouch.
Installing the Pegs
After the varnish had hardened a little more, I then installed the pegs.
Pegs installed, Front view.
Bass side view with Pegs.
Back Side View with Pegs.
Finishing: Final Set-up
I installed the Bridge and Strings and Tailpiece, and then the fiddle was complete. I still let it hang in my dining room for a week or so, too, so that the varnish would continue to harden without damage.
Hanging up to cure.
Final photos
Final look at the Front before delivery.
Close-up of the f-hole on the Oregon Douglas Fir Front.
Bass side: final look before delivery.
Close up of the Scroll.
Final look at the back of the fiddle before delivery.
I prepared the instrument’s documents (Bill of Sale and Provenance Document) and afterward, when the varnish had cured for another two weeks, the customer took delivery at the end of July, 2023. That is when “Finishing” is completed!
He was delighted, and played the instrument for a long time at my house. Further (which is a joy to me,) he has contacted me since then, expressing his continued joy in the new fiddle. That is the kind of thing that makes this work a great pleasure.
So, when I saw that there were two sections of “scrap” left over, near where the neck end of the five-string double bass back was cut out, I realized that a 5-string fiddle back could fit into each of those two pieces.
So, I salvaged the wood, and not only got two backs, but also the neck blanks for two 5-string fiddles.
Five-string fiddle back cut from the scrap left from a 5-string double bass back.
Arching the Plate
Five string fiddle begun, with back and neck from scrap from a 5-string double bass back.
I really like the look of the Oregon Big Leaf Maple back wood. I enjoyed arching the plate.
Five-string fiddle back arching nearly complete. It is sitting on the five-string double bass garland whose back provided the scrap for the fiddle-back.
Purfling the Plate
On all my five-string instruments I usually include a purfling weave. It is a modified fleur-de-lis I designed for my first five-string fiddle and have continued to use on subsequent work.
Five-string fiddle back with purfling slots incised and ready to complete.
In this photo, the slots for the purfling have been incised, but not cut deeply, so the next step is to slice deeply enough that the waste wood can be removed from between the cuts, and the purfling strips inlaid in the resulting slot.
I will include the purfling process in subsequent posts.
It has been a frustrating series of weeks: all the usual responsibilities, house guests, etc., plus a few unexpected items. The lawn tractor suddenly quit mowing, though it ran fine. We narrowed it down to being a bad PTO clutch, so that is just another thing to take apart and replace. Guess that’s what happens when you use 30-year-old equipment. 🙂
Then, two days ago, my beloved better half, Ann, discovered that the side porch steps are in advanced stages of rot…so, today, we went and bought all the pressure-treated lumber to replace them. They, too, have been in place for over 30 years, so, I guess, they have served well.
Progress on the 5-String Fiddles
I did manage to make a little progress on some of the acoustic five-string fiddles I had begun, however:
All the linings are in place for two of the instruments (violin and the 14-7/8″ viola.)
The front and back plates are traced and cut out for both of those instruments.
The front plate graduations are complete for the 14″ viola, and
The f-holes are cut out on the 14″ viola, but not refined.
So, this is where things stand, at the moment:
Here is the “Strobelesque” garland with its front and back plates:
Rib Garland and rough-cut plates for the “Strobelesque” fiddle.
No carving at all has been done on the plates, and the Sitka Spruce front plate is still nearly an inch thick. I will plane it down before I begin arching, of course. I do like the look of the spalted maple back and ribs. This maple was from an old Big Leaf Maple tree on the property where Ann grew up. It had begun to show signs of decay, and was removed for safety’s sake. Too bad for the loss of the tree, but it is nice wood.
Here is the 14-7/8″ Viola garland with its front and back plates.
Rib garland with front and back plates for a 14-7/8″ 5-string viola.
This one is my own design. In fact, it was the very first form I ever made, thinking I was just going to make a viola for my youngest son (whose name is on the form, along with the date: 1999.) As it happened, I discovered that lutherie is addictive, and I have been building instruments ever since. 🙂
The center-lines on both plates are ink, not a glue-line: this instrument boasts both a one-piece Spalted (Big-Leaf) Maple back plate (also from the tree at Ann’s childhood home) and a one-piece Sitka Spruce front plate.
Here is the progress on the 14″ Viola:
Rib garland and nearly completed plates for a 14″ five-string viola.
This one is my own design, too: it is the same length as a standard violin, but much wider in the lower bouts, and deeper in the ribs. It will be interesting to see how it works as a five-string fiddle. (This is a first.) This one has an Englemann Spruce front plate and a one-piece Big Leaf Maple back from a log I was given by Terry Howell, years ago.
I will post more reports as the work takes place. Feel free to contact me if you have questions.
The last time I presented anything about these instruments, I think it was on another site, so– here is how they looked at that time (earlier this week, perhaps.)
Blocks installed, and necks cut out.
In the above photo, all you can see is three violin forms, with blocks installed, and some of the wood that will go into each, including the necks. I already had a fourth instrument (a small viola) begun, which was not in the picture.
So, here is that 14″ 5-string viola, well on the way to completion, but still with a long way to go…as of today.
14″ viola 5-string in progress.
And, as promised, here is a progress report on the other three:
5-string 14-7/8″ viola in progress.
On this instrument, the ribs are installed, but no linings as yet, and, while the Maple and Spruce have been selected for the front and back plates, they are essentially untouched. The neck has been traced out and the outline cut, but it, too, has far to go.
Guarneri-form 5-string fiddle in progress.
For this instrument, a five-string fiddle being built on the form of the 1735 “Plowden” Guarneri del Gesu, I had a top plate left from a previous project on the same form, so I opted to use it, with the spalted Big Leaf Maple back and ribs. No linings, yet, but they have been bent and are ready to install. The neck is from a different Big Leaf Maple, which came from the yard of the property where my wife grew up.
5-string fiddle on “Strobelesque” form, in progress.
Henry (Senior) would not have recognized this form, but it was loosely derived from the form in Henry Strobel’s book, “Violin-making, Step-by-Step”…so it is called “Strobelesque.” In this photo, the glue was not dry on the treble-side upper rib, but I didn’t want to wait, so I took the photo with the clamps still in place. Again, no linings, yet, but they are bent and ready to install. Here, too, I had a partially completed top plate, and elected to use it. The back and sides are heavily spalted Big Leaf Maple, and the neck is also Big Leaf Maple, though from a different tree…the one in my Father-in-Law’s yard. A few years ago, they decided that tree had enough rot to be dangerous, so they took it out, but it provided wood for a number of instruments.
My son Brian Bishop builds high-quality guitars, and managed to salvage several guitar sets beside the various violin and viola sets I saved. I got one cello set out of it, too…it will become a cello for my beloved wife.